Reviews

Records the editors have actually sat with, scored out of ten. A high mark is an argument, not a favour, and the write-up has to earn it.

Dark Asylum

Kamelot — Dark Asylum

7.0 Critic
Sep 5, 2026

Three reviewers who agree on nothing else about this record agree about one thing, and it is a mixing decision. Angry Metal Guy, The Progres...

The Squirrely Years Revisited

Ministry — The Squirrely Years Revisited

6.5 Critic
Aug 27, 2026

Some context you need before the first note. Al Jourgensen has spent four decades disowning Ministry's early synth-pop records, and he did n...

An Insatiable Violence

Cryptopsy — An Insatiable Violence

8.5 Critic
Aug 13, 2026

Matt McGachy told Blabbermouth what the plan was before anybody had heard a note of this thing.We really wanted to make a groovy record, and...

Wheels of Steel

Saxon — Wheels of Steel

8.5 Critic
Aug 1, 2026

Biff Byford has never dressed this up. The first album, he told Louder years later, had sold about twelve thousand copies, mainly to people...

Where Only the Truth Is Spoken

Malevolence — Where Only the Truth Is Spoken

7.5 Critic
Jul 22, 2026

A hardcore band from Sheffield that started its own label because no label would do it properly has now made a record in Dave Grohl's studio...

De Profundis

Vader — De Profundis

9.0 Critic
Jul 10, 2026

The Polish quartet from Olsztyn had one studio album and one live record behind it when it entered Studio Modern Sound in Gdynia in May 1995...

Blackbraid III

Blackbraid — Blackbraid III

8.0 Critic
Jul 1, 2026

The verdict first, because the record deserves a straight answer rather than a lap of honour: this is the most assured thing the project has...

The End of Heartache

Killswitch Engage — The End of Heartache

9.0 Critic
Jun 20, 2026

Every band you saw in a van between 2005 and 2010 was chasing this record. Some of them knew it. Most of them thought they had come up with...

Gothic

Paradise Lost — Gothic

8.8 Critic
Jun 11, 2026

Picture the room, because the room explains the record. Academy Studios in West Yorkshire, the winter of 1990 turning into 1991, five men in...

The Shit ov God

Behemoth — The Shit ov God

7.5 Critic
Jun 3, 2026

On 29 January 2025 the band released a single and, with it, the title of the album it came from, and the reaction to those four words occupi...

Nightfall in Middle-Earth

Blind Guardian — Nightfall in Middle-Earth

8.8 Critic
May 23, 2026

Count the tracks before you argue about anything else. Twenty two are listed. Eleven are songs. The other eleven run between twenty one seco...

The Arsonist

Sodom — The Arsonist

8.0 Critic
May 16, 2026

No triggers. No samples. No plug-ins on the snare. The drums went to tape the way drums went to tape in 1986, and the man who decided that h...

Streetcleaner

Godflesh — Streetcleaner

9.1 Critic
May 7, 2026

Put this on and listen to what is missing. There is no fill. Nowhere in fifty two minutes does anything speed up because a human being got e...

In the Nightside Eclipse

Emperor — In the Nightside Eclipse

9.2 Critic
Apr 28, 2026

In July 1993, four musicians from Notodden carried their equipment into a Bergen concert hall that Eirik Hundvin had converted into a studio...

Hymns in Dissonance

Whitechapel — Hymns in Dissonance

8.5 Critic
Apr 21, 2026

Two albums ago this band was writing about childhood trauma with clean vocals and acoustic guitars, and doing it well. This one opens with a...

Scum

Napalm Death — Scum

8.8 Critic
Apr 9, 2026

Nobody agrees how long "You Suffer" is. The Bandcamp listing says four seconds. Other pressings say three, or one, and the figure that gets...

Sleepless Empire

Lacuna Coil — Sleepless Empire

7.0 Critic
Apr 2, 2026

The argument this record walks into is one the band cannot win by volume alone. After nearly thirty years and a stretch of albums that drift...

Altars of Madness

Morbid Angel — Altars of Madness

9.3 Critic
Mar 24, 2026

Eighteen months. That is how long American record shops waited for the album that rebuilt American death metal, because Earache put it out i...

Die for Us

Werewolves — Die for Us

9.0 Critic
Mar 18, 2026

Australia's most savage death metal band, Werewolves, returns with their fifth studio album, Die For Us. Known for their relentless brutalit...

Gilded Sorrow

The Obsessed — Gilded Sorrow

8.0 Critic
Mar 11, 2026

The Return of The ObsessedAfter a seven-year gap following Sacred, Wino returns with Gilded Sorrow, an album that merges 70s hard rock with...