A sheet of linen stretched across a doorway, an oil lantern burning behind it, and four men crouched at the back of the booth working cut-paper figures on sticks, so that the crowd on the bright side sees nothing of the hands and everything of the giants they throw. That is how the old shadow theatres ran, and it is the nearest thing I know to the way Cirith Ungol have always run: a small crew from Ventura, California, a lamp kept alight for longer than anyone had a right to expect, and monsters on the screen three times the height of the men making them. On All the Shadows there is one pair of hands fewer behind the linen than last time. The flame behind the linen is as hot as ever.
Recorded at The Captains Quarters in Ventura, produced by the band with Armand John Anthony, who also engineered, mixed and mastered it, and released by No Remorse Records on 30 October 2026, three years after Dark Parade, this seventh studio album comes from a band that announced in October 2023 it would stop playing live after 2024, then lost both of its guitarists, Jimmy Barraza and Greg Lindstrom, and still quietly declined to go home. Anthony stepped out of the control room to fill the gap. He had already recorded the band's recent albums at his studio and plays beside bassist Jarvis Leatherby in Night Demon, so the five of Dark Parade became the four of this record: Tim Baker on vocals, Anthony on guitar, Leatherby on bass, Robert Garven on drums. One guitarist where there were two. That is the whole line-up story, and it is bigger than it looks.
The figures on the screen
The light this booth throws is the old light. The riffs are rooted in the 1970s and lean hard on the Sabbath end of the cupboard, slow-burning, riff first and everything else trimmed to fit around it, and the production gives them a full, warm, vintage body instead of the buffed chrome of a modern metal record. The title track, "All the Shadows", opens the show the way a puppeteer opens with his biggest figure, and that figure is Baker. His voice is still the signature of the band, beyond dispute, and the reason nobody mistakes it for anyone else: menacing, raw, eccentric, a cut-paper demon with its jaw on a pin, flung across the linen until its silhouette swallows the whole screen and the front row leans back in its seat. He makes no concession to good manners. He never has.
Anthony is the new figure behind the lamp, and the record's argument rests on him. His leads and solos are where the best minutes of All the Shadows are kept, and what he plays is not a tracing of the old outline but a fresh figure cut from the same pattern, and to my mind a little more melodic than the pair who went before him. "Shadow Reflection" is where that pays off first, the guitar harmonies galloping in a way that would not embarrass a certain East London institution, and "Hollow Nimbus" pushes the clock further back still, into a seventies, almost progressive drift crowned by a solo that I would rank among his best here.
Baker throws the giant on the wall, and Anthony keeps the lamp trimmed behind him.
Then there is "On Broken Wings", at seven minutes and eighteen seconds the longest thing here and the centre of the whole spectacle. It opens on acoustic guitar, swings between quiet and loud like a lantern carried from one end of the booth to the other, and lands a melodic solo that makes the case for Anthony better than any paragraph can. Some will hear a power ballad that stays too long. That is the one moment where the band lets the shadow shrink to human size before throwing it up the wall again, and that contrast is worth every one of its minutes. "Empty Tomb", one of three songs under four minutes, does the opposite job: a compact piece of business at three minutes and forty-nine seconds that cuts its figure, crosses the screen and leaves.
Where the paper tears
Not every figure moves. The record is uneven, and the dips are easy to point to. "This Mortal Stain", at five minutes and forty-two seconds, drags its leaden silhouette from one edge of the screen to the other long after the audience has understood the shape. "Turning Blind" is where this record divides a room. Hear the half-spoken menace as theatre and it is a creeping, sinister set piece; hear it as a song wandering the stage in search of its mark and it is the weakest four minutes and forty-five seconds on the album. I side with the second reading. A shadow play lives on movement, and that one stands still.
"Venus in Thirds" closes at three minutes and thirty-five seconds, brisk, more a curtain call than a finale. It is a good song and a slight ending, and a band with Baker's theatrical instincts could have staged a bigger last scene.
Here is who this is for. The faithful who have kept King of the Dead and Frost and Fire within reach for four decades will find the same lantern, the same linen and the same grotesque giants, now worked by a smaller and steadier crew, and will not be disappointed. Anyone hoping that a band that had said it would stop playing live would spend its last oil on something it had never tried will find a solid, uneven, often thrilling record of the old kind instead. That is no small thing to come from a booth that had already said its touring days were numbered.