Heavy Metal Album Reviews

Every Heavy Metal record the editors have reviewed, scored out of ten.

27 reviews

Cirith Ungol — All the Shadows 7.5

Cirith Ungol

All the Shadows

2026 · Heavy Metal

The old lantern still throws giants, though some figures repeat their walk

Declan Rourke Nov 8, 2026

All That Remains — A War You Cannot Win 7.0

All That Remains

A War You Cannot Win

2012 · Heavy Metal

The pit half wins the argument, the radio half won the charts.

Jonah Pike Nov 6, 2026

Temperance — Arcani 7.5

Temperance

Arcani

2026 · Heavy Metal

Thirteen cards dealt with real skill, and you can call the spread

Julien Vasseur Nov 3, 2026

U.D.O. — Animal House 7.5

U.D.O.

Animal House

1987 · Heavy Metal

Accept built every room; the new tenants never quite fill them.

Declan Rourke Nov 3, 2026

GWAR — War Party 7.5

GWAR

War Party

2004 · Heavy Metal

GWAR's heaviest manifesto, loud at the rally, thin by the last stop.

Declan Rourke Oct 26, 2026

Armored Saint — Punching the Sky 8.5

Armored Saint

Punching the Sky

2020 · Heavy Metal

Five old soldiers, one piper, and not one concession to the calendar.

Declan Rourke Oct 23, 2026

Sodom — M-16 8.5

Sodom

M-16

2001 · Heavy Metal

A whole war fed through one ammunition belt, and only the mix jams.

Saint Sylveszter Oct 22, 2026

GWAR — The Blood of Gods 7.0

GWAR

The Blood of Gods

2017 · Heavy Metal

The monsters went rock and roll, and the jokes got old faster.

Saint Sylveszter Oct 19, 2026

Darkthrone — Dark Thrones and Black Flags 7.0

Darkthrone

Dark Thrones and Black Flags

2008 · Heavy Metal

Rough by choice, sharper than it pretends, and still half punk.

Eirik Solvang Oct 19, 2026

Doro — Raise Your Fist 7.5

Doro

Raise Your Fist

2012 · Heavy Metal

Too long by three songs, and stronger than it had any need to be.

Declan Rourke Oct 17, 2026

Queensryche — Promised Land 8.5

Queensryche

Promised Land

1994 · Heavy Metal

A platinum band spent its fortune on silence, and was right to.

Julien Vasseur Oct 16, 2026

ADX — Immortel 7.0

ADX

Immortel

2011 · Heavy Metal

A fast, dark French blade that fourteen songs blunt.

Saint Sylveszter Oct 16, 2026

Tygers of Pan Tang — Electrifyed 8.0

Tygers of Pan Tang

Electrifyed

2026 · Heavy Metal

The old station runs hot again, right up to its rated load

Declan Rourke Sep 17, 2026

Judas Priest — Painkiller 9.3

Judas Priest

Painkiller

1990 · Heavy Metal

Priest light the afterburners and leave a whole genre chasing the vapour trail

Declan Rourke Sep 11, 2026

Megadeth — Rust in Peace 9.3

Megadeth

Rust in Peace

1990 · Heavy Metal

Thrash wound to the last tooth, with only the voice running rough.

Saint Sylveszter Sep 4, 2026

The Night Eternal — Cold Velvet 8.5

The Night Eternal

Cold Velvet

2026 · Heavy Metal

Velvet cut close over steel, with a single seam pulling loose.

Declan Rourke Aug 29, 2026

Pantera — Vulgar Display of Power 9.0

Pantera

Vulgar Display of Power

1992 · Heavy Metal

Six bare-knuckle shots flatten the room, and the rest is a victory lap

Jonah Pike Aug 22, 2026

Iron Maiden — The Number of the Beast 9.4

Iron Maiden

The Number of the Beast

1982 · Heavy Metal

One lame horse in the column, and still the charge that took the field.

Declan Rourke Aug 20, 2026

Black Sabbath — Paranoid 9.5

Black Sabbath

Paranoid

1970 · Heavy Metal

Poured in days, and the whole genre is still cooling around it

Ilse Brandt Aug 18, 2026

Metallica — Master of Puppets 9.5

Metallica

Master of Puppets

1986 · Heavy Metal

The siege that broke thrash open, fought twice from the same plans

Saint Sylveszter Aug 17, 2026

Saxon — Wheels of Steel 8.5

Saxon

Wheels of Steel

1980 · Heavy Metal

The album that bought a career, and still sounds like it knew.

Declan Rourke Aug 1, 2026

Blind Guardian — Nightfall in Middle-Earth 8.8

Blind Guardian

Nightfall in Middle-Earth

1998 · Heavy Metal

Eleven songs of genuine grandeur, and eleven fragments that are not songs.

Julien Vasseur May 23, 2026

Sodom — The Arsonist 8.0

Sodom

The Arsonist

2025 · Heavy Metal

Analogue drums, four decades in, and nowhere to play it.

Declan Rourke May 16, 2026

Darkthrone — It Beckons Us All....... 7.5

Darkthrone

It Beckons Us All.......

2024 · Heavy Metal

It Beckons Us All opens with "Howling Primitive Colonies," immediately immersing listeners in a dense, doom-laden atmosp...

Eirik Solvang Jun 8, 2024