Reviews

Records the editors have actually sat with, scored out of ten. A high mark is an argument, not a favour, and the write-up has to earn it.

58 reviews · Clear filters

Kreator — Coma of Souls 8.5

Kreator

Coma of Souls

1990 · Thrash Metal

Kreator traded a little fury for aim, and nearly every shot lands.

Declan Rourke Nov 6, 2026

Dark Tranquillity — Atoma 8.0

Dark Tranquillity

Atoma

2016 · Death Metal

Twenty years of ore poured into one hard ingot, slag and all.

Rafael Quintero Nov 4, 2026

Devin Townsend — Lightwork 8.0

Devin Townsend

Lightwork

2022 · Progressive Metal

Thirty years of held chords, and at last the pedal lifts.

Julien Vasseur Nov 4, 2026

TDI
8.5

Converge

The Dusk in Us

2017 · Hardcore

Hardcore on a leash, until the title track chews straight through it.

Jonah Pike Nov 3, 2026

Nile — Those Whom the Gods Detest 8.0

Nile

Those Whom the Gods Detest

2009 · Death Metal

Nile's cleanest embalming job, with one ritual left too long in the air.

Rafael Quintero Nov 3, 2026

Borknagar — The Archaic Course 8.0

Borknagar

The Archaic Course

1998 · Black Metal

A blade pulled from the quench too soon, keen everywhere except two notches.

Eirik Solvang Oct 26, 2026

Alcest — Spiritual Instinct 8.0

Alcest

Spiritual Instinct

2019 · Black Metal

The dream smashed on the floor, every shard reflecting a familiar face.

Eirik Solvang Oct 25, 2026

Gaerea — Coma 8.0

Gaerea

Coma

2024 · Black Metal

Ten songs in black ink, with the white paper finally left showing.

Andrzej Sawicki Oct 25, 2026

Iotunn — Kinship 8.5

Iotunn

Kinship

2024 · Power Metal

One voice carries the whole cycle; only the coda forgets to begin.

Julien Vasseur Oct 25, 2026

Blut aus Nord — MoRT 8.0

Blut aus Nord

MoRT

2006 · Black Metal

Black metal on an iron lung, breathing on schedule, never once alive.

Eirik Solvang Oct 23, 2026

Hypocrisy — A Taste of Extreme Divinity 8.0

Hypocrisy

A Taste of Extreme Divinity

2009 · Death Metal

A career's bones, exhumed and shelved in order, without a single new one.

Andrzej Sawicki Oct 23, 2026

Dark Tranquillity — Where Death Is Most Alive 8.0

Dark Tranquillity

Where Death Is Most Alive

2009 · Death Metal · Live

A wake for a doomed club, played loud enough to rouse its dead.

Rafael Quintero Oct 23, 2026

Devin Townsend — Order of Magnitude: Empath Live Volume 1 8.0

Devin Townsend

Order of Magnitude: Empath Live Volume 1

2020 · Progressive Metal · Live

Ten players, no click track, and a dense arrangement that survives daylight.

Julien Vasseur Oct 23, 2026

Armored Saint — Punching the Sky 8.5

Armored Saint

Punching the Sky

2020 · Heavy Metal

Five old soldiers, one piper, and not one concession to the calendar.

Declan Rourke Oct 23, 2026

Slayer — Decade of Aggression 8.0

Slayer

Decade of Aggression

1991 · Thrash Metal · Live

The classic four's flight recorder, left unedited and still screaming.

Declan Rourke Oct 22, 2026

Borknagar — Empiricism 8.5

Borknagar

Empiricism

2001 · Black Metal

The black cathedral rebuilt as an observatory, and the telescope works.

Eirik Solvang Oct 22, 2026

Sodom — M-16 8.5

Sodom

M-16

2001 · Heavy Metal

A whole war fed through one ammunition belt, and only the mix jams.

Saint Sylveszter Oct 22, 2026

Cradle of Filth — Existence Is Futile 8.0

Cradle of Filth

Existence Is Futile

2021 · Death Metal

The old score, played louder, in an opera house on fire.

Andrzej Sawicki Oct 22, 2026

Dream Theater — A View from the Top of the World 8.0

Dream Theater

A View from the Top of the World

2021 · Progressive Metal

Magnificent at altitude, and wedged exactly where the last climb stopped.

Julien Vasseur Oct 22, 2026

Nine Inch Nails — Pretty Hate Machine 8.0

Nine Inch Nails

Pretty Hate Machine

1989 · Industrial Metal

Synth-pop wired to a car battery, dated in sound and timeless in nerve.

Curtis Vance Oct 19, 2026

Amenra — Mass VI 8.5

Amenra

Mass VI

2017 · Doom Metal

Six pieces of grief that weigh more than any riff on them.

Ilse Brandt Oct 19, 2026

Deicide — Serpents of the Light 8.0

Deicide

Serpents of the Light

1997 · Death Metal

Thirty minutes of Tampa death metal with the hooks left in.

Rafael Quintero Oct 19, 2026

Angelus Apatrida — Aftermath 8.0

Angelus Apatrida

Aftermath

2023 · Thrash Metal

Spanish thrash veterans open every door, and most of them lead somewhere.

Declan Rourke Oct 19, 2026

Queensryche — Promised Land 8.5

Queensryche

Promised Land

1994 · Heavy Metal

A platinum band spent its fortune on silence, and was right to.

Julien Vasseur Oct 16, 2026